00:00:00TEWES: This is a second interview with Susan Kitazawa for the Japanese American
Intergenerational Narratives Oral History Project. The interview is being
conducted by Amanda Tewes on January 24, 2022. Ms. Kitazawa joins me from San
Francisco, California, and I am in Walnut Creek, California. So thank you,
Susan, for joining for a second session.
KITAZAWA: Thank you for having me.
TEWES: As we left off last time, we were speaking about your life and work and
experiences in the Japanese American community. But I wanted to start off this
time thinking specifically about your family's experience with incarceration. I
thought we'd break this up perhaps into the two sides of your family. So first
could you tell me a little bit more about your paternal family's experiences
during World War II?
KITAZAWA: Yes, I would be happy
00:01:00to. My father's parents were working their very, very small family flower
nursery in San José at the time that people were taken for incarceration. It was
a tiny nursery, just the two of them worked at it. And when my father had been
at home, he worked with them. And at one point, they had a helper man who worked
there, but that's it. It was their work. It wasn't like a big fancy business.
And so they were taken from there to Manzanar, as were my mother and father. And
my father told us that for his father, I mean, even though he wasn't happy about
being taken away from his home and his nursery, that he was able to sell, on
paper sell the family nursery and business to people at the Quaker Meeting House
in San José, where he
00:02:00was a weekend custodian. So they bought the place on paper for a dollar and they
held it for them until they came back home again, which was really fortunate
that they had that connection to people in the white community. Didn't lose
their land or have to sell it super cheap, because they only had like less than
a week to sell things when people were taken.
So anyway, they went to Manzanar. And it's amazing. My father talked about his
father -- he was very proud and happy, my grandfather, because according to my
father, he was put in charge of the victory garden, the vegetable garden that
grew a lot of the produce that was used in the kitchen and the dining hall
there. And so he had a role that was, from his point of view, important, and it
was also related to his normal life work, which was in small agriculture.
00:03:00Then my father said that his mother was actually fairly happy being
incarcerated. I mean, she didn't like being incarcerated, but she was fairly
happy being in the setting where they were, even though it was very primitive
and rough, because working seven days a week, long, long hours keeping the
nursery going was a lot of really hard physical labor. So she didn't have to do
as much physical labor when she was incarcerated, and also because she was
immersed in Japanese community, lots and lots of Japanese speaking people. My
grandfather was reasonably bilingual in English, because of needing to have
business transactions with his nursery, but my grandmother really had very
limited English. So for her to all of a sudden be with a whole lot of
Japanese-speaking people, my father said she felt that was all right. So that was
00:04:00their day-to-day life.
And then my father worked on the -- should I talk about the Guayule Project now
or does that come later?
TEWES: Well, maybe we'll wait just a second here. I'm interested, because I
don't think a lot of people from San José went to Manzanar. Do you know why the
family went there?
KITAZAWA: Yes. It was because my mother and my father, separately from each
other -- they didn't live together or know each other or anything -- they were
both assigned to Manzanar, because there was a project called the Guayule
Project. G-u-a-y-u-l-e, I think. It's a kind of cactus, Guayule is the Spanish
name for the cactus. And there was an effort to synthesize rubber from the sap
from the Guayule Project, and they actually succeeded in doing it. So there were
science people who I think were connected to UC
00:05:00Berkeley, where my parents were both graduate students. So that's how my
parents, individually, separately from each other, got assigned to Manzanar. And
then because they were assigned there, the government sent both my mother's
parents and my father's parents to the same camp, I guess in maybe some effort
not to split up families. One likes to think it was for that.
TEWES: Okay. I was like, that's so unusual.
KITAZAWA: Yeah.
TEWES: And did your father have any siblings?
KITAZAWA: He had a brother and a sister, but when he was nine years old, his
four-year-old sister and his six-month-old brother both died within one week. My
father said they both contracted tuberculosis and passed away. The story is the
hired worker who worked at the nursery with the
00:06:00family had TB and that the kids got it from him. So this was all like family
legend. Who knows what exactly happened? But they both had a respiratory
illness, a severe respiratory illness, and they died within, I think, three or
four days of each other when they were little, when my father was nine years old.
TEWES: Oh my goodness.
KITAZAWA: Yeah. So he was not only the oldest son, the oldest child, but he was
also the only surviving child, which put a huge amount of pressure on him just
to be the perfect kid and be there for his parents and do everything right. He
never spoke about it until he was much, much, much older. One day he just
suddenly started talking about his brother and sister. I knew as a child that
his brother and sister had died when they were young, but I didn't know any
details. It
00:07:00was like Manzanar. You just weren't supposed to talk with him about it.
TEWES: Yeah. Did they have extended family who were able to come to Manzanar
with him?
KITAZAWA: I'm not exactly sure where my grandmother's sister and my
grandfather's brother went. I think they went someplace else. I should know
this, but I don't know. My father's parents just had the three kids and the two
died in childhood, so they just had him. so they were the really small family.
And then the aunt and uncle, which was my grandmother's sister and my
grandfather's brother, were married and they had a slew of kids. And not sure
where everybody went.
TEWES: Okay. And I'm curious about, before removal, what your
00:08:00father's family was doing. He was at Berkeley in grad school. They were in San
José with the nursery. Did they talk about the time after Pearl Harbor at all
and what those moments were like?
KITAZAWA: I don't remember anybody talking about that. I think the main thing I
remember about after Pearl Harbor was them going out onto the street from
wherever they were inside. I mean, the signs were, I think, only in English. But
I remember my parents talking about going on the street and seeing those signs,
which many people have seen, the executive order signs like tacked up on windows
and telephone poles. They were out there in public just saying, "If you're of
Japanese ancestry, on this date at this time you need to show up at such and
such a place."
00:09:00And the whole thing of being shipped off to camp, it was very sudden. It was
just like you get up in the morning to go to class, and all of a sudden, you
find out that if you're even partly of Japanese ancestry you need to show up at
this place. I think it was like a depot or a train station or some kind of a
transportation thing. And so you knew you were going to go someplace. And I
don't know how they heard about the rules, that you could only take two pieces
of luggage and whatever you took with you, you had to be able to carry yourself.
Just the suddenness of it, I think that was the main thing that they talked
about, was just the sudden, unexpected mess of, okay, your life has just been
torn apart and you need to pack up what you can carry and show up at this place,
the assembly center, for whatever was going to happen to you next, and not
knowing what was going to
00:10:00happen to you.
TEWES: Yeah. You do a good job speaking about the suddenness here. Do you know
which assembly center they were sent to?
KITAZAWA: They went to Tanforan, like by the Tanforan Shopping Center, which I
believe was the racetrack. And they were there. And so then I think from
Tanforan, they got sent to I think it's Santa Anita in Southern California,
which was also a racetrack. They slept in the stables there. They were recently
used for horses, so it was like straw and manure and that kind of thing. And
they slept there. I don't know how long they were
00:11:00there. And then from there, they got up on the train to go to Manzanar, I
believe. They didn't talk about it a whole lot earlier on, but to the extent
that they talked about it, it was just the whole thing of having to show up at
an assembly center, which you didn't know exactly what was going to happen, and
then I think they got bused to Tanforan and there was the racetrack or horse
stalls or something there, and then being sent probably by bus to Santa Anita
with more racetrack, horse stall reality, and then from there to Manzanar. And
through all of this, you don't know what's going on. Are you like the Jews in
Germany? They're sending you off to be gassed. Or are they going to keep you
00:12:00for a while in the horse stalls and let you go? Just having absolutely no idea
what was going to happen to you. I think that was the biggest, biggest
impression that they left us with as kids, was just the utter uncertainty of it.
And so not only is your life completely disrupted, but you're put in this
situation where you don't know where you're going to be in a week or you don't
know if you're going to be alive in a week. You just don't know and nobody's
telling you what's going on. And just lots of soldiers, US military people with
guns and very clearly you had to do what they were telling you, because they had
guns. And it didn't make any sense. It's just like, Oh my goodness, how could
this be happening? And I think especially for someone who's a US born
00:13:00citizen, who supposedly has rights, you realize that your rights don't matter
and that you are in this situation over which you have no control and about
which you have almost no information.
TEWES: Thank you for that. We'll speak about your parents a little bit
separately. But I am curious about your paternal grandparents. They chose to
return to the San José area after incarceration?
KITAZAWA: Yes. Yes, yes. They went back to their nursery, they went back to
their land. And they bought it back from the Quaker Meeting House people who had
held it them, so they didn't lose their land. Many, many other people lost
whatever real estate they had, land or housing or whatever, if they owned it,
because of the
00:14:00extremely short notice on which you had to leave. And so people were trying to
sell their furniture and their homes and everything. And so obviously if people
know that you're going to be shipped off in a few days, they can bid really low
for whatever you're trying to sell. You're between a rock and a hard place and
you have to sell it for whatever you can get. But my grandparents were very
fortunate in that way, that they had the Quaker Meeting House connection,
because my grandfather was the cleaning man on the weekend.
TEWES: Yes, thank you.
KITAZAWA: That wasn't their church. They went to Wesley United Methodist Church,
which was a traditionally Japanese immigrant church. They were Methodists, but
he was the cleaning man at the Quaker Meeting
00:15:00 House.
TEWES: I'd also like to speak about your maternal family's experiences during
this time. You spoke a little bit about the grandparents who lived at a boys'
school, but I'll let you pick up from here.
KITAZAWA: Okay. [Their names were Shigeji and Kaoru Makino.] My mother's father
worked as the live on-site cook at a private boarding school for wealthy boys.
Obviously wealthy white boys. That was in Los Gatos. And he worked seven days a
week. And he and my grandmother and their three children, my mom and two younger
siblings, lived in what was described to me as a cinderblock -- they called it a
cinderblock house, but it sounds like it was more like a shack. I think it was
tiny, tiny and it was behind the dining hall where my grandfather
00:16:00worked. Well, he had cooked in the past for rich people in different capacities,
so he had experience as a cook. But I think he chose that job partly because it
was at a boarding school, and since my grandmother was ill with schizophrenia
and not really very functional, by having a job at a boarding school, part of
the deal was that his kids got to attend school at the boarding school, which
was kind of an amazing fringe benefit. I mean, he was paid very little. They're
living in kind of a cinderblock shack. He's working seven days a week, split
shifts. Lots of working people know split shifts, like you get up at 4:00 and
you work the breakfast and feed breakfast and clean up from breakfast and then
you have two hours off and then you work again, do the same thing for
00:17:00lunch, and then you have two hours off and then you work again to do dinner and
then you're done at 7:00 at night and you go to bed and go back to work at 4:00
in the morning. So you don't really do anything except work. That was his life.
So Grandma just stayed in the back of the dining hall in the cinderblock shack
place. I guess she could go out of the building, kind of wander around, that way
he could kind of keep an eye on her. And then the kids were busy during the day
at school, because they were allowed to go to class with the wealthy kids. For
my uncle, because he was a boy, that worked out pretty well for him. He had lots
of male playmates and he got to be close with the headmaster's son and other key
people. And then my mom and my aunt, they were the two girl students at an
all-male school, so I think that was kind of weird for
00:18:00them. Because it was a private residential school for rich kids, my mom said
that often in class it would be like a one-to-four ratio. Like there would be a
teacher and four students or a teacher and six students. Not like a regular
school. And the teachers, according to my mom, were very, very good. My aunt and
my mom and my uncle all talked about how they got this very, very, very good
education compared to somebody who would be going to a regular public school.
And then later, I know my mom went to the public high school. I remember that. I
don't know much about it, but I know that she went on the bus or something to
the public high school in Los Gatos. And I'm not sure about my aunt. And then
later my mom, when she was
00:19:00fourteen, was sent to live at the YWCA in San Francisco, which was a Japanese
American at the Y at the time, the one in J-town. And she finished her last two
years of high school there and then she went to Berkeley at sixteen. My mom was
really, really, really smart.
TEWES: Yes.
KITAZAWA: My aunt stayed at the boarding school through high school, I believe.
And then my uncle, their brother, when it was time for people to be incarcerated
-- yeah, he was much younger than them, so he was still at the school. My mom
was off at Berkeley in grad school when incarceration came. My aunt had just
gotten accepted at UCSF [University of California, San Francisco] Nursing
School, and she was really excited about going there. But she never
00:20:00got to go there, because then she was incarcerated before her program began.
And then my uncle, who was the youngest one, he was still at home. And so when
it was time for people to be incarcerated, the headmaster and the powers-that-be
at the school, because they had connections, they worked it out for him to go to
be at a dude ranch, which I think was in Colorado. It was somewhere in the
mountains. And it was a dude ranch where rich people went to go on trail rides.
They would stay in the facilities up there and pretend they were cowboys for a
week for vacation. And so my [uncle] was passed off as a Native American to the
school, and he led trail rides and things and took care of the horses and
whatnot. I think he was the only one of my
00:21:00relatives who was living in the United States at that time who wasn't
incarcerated. And then, of course, my relatives in Japan weren't. But I think
Uncle Ernie was the only one that was not incarcerated. And he loved horses. He
later became a veterinarian. So for him this was kind of super wonderful, other
than the fact that I think he was still a teenager and was separated from his
family. But sometimes when you're a teenage boy being separated from your
family, a lot of teenage boys would think that was all right. And he got to ride
horses at an okay place to stay. And he lived with the other people who were
doing the same work. I think they had a bunkhouse or something. So anyway, that
was his experience. And years and years later, after my mom had already passed
away and my uncle was toward the end of his life and he got together with his
00:22:00younger sister, my aunt -- and she told me later he was crying and said he just
was so, so sorry he had abandoned the family, and that he had always felt guilt
that they were all locked up while he was riding around on horses in the
mountains, and that he had always carried this huge shame and guilt that he
hadn't been there for the family. My aunt was amazed that he had felt that way
and that he had carried that feeling with him through all those years. I mean,
they were in their eighties when this was happening, when he was apologizing and crying.
TEWES: Do you know how the rest of the family felt about that?
KITAZAWA: He was the baby, because he was the younger brother, and he was a good
bit younger than the two sisters. And so they were just really grateful that
their baby brother, their kid brother -- he wasn't a baby, he was in high
school, I think --
00:23:00but that he had been saved from that experience.
TEWES: I also think it's interesting that one of your sisters ended up working
for the Indian Health Service, I think. So there's this long connection there.
KITAZAWA: Yeah, yeah. My Uncle Ernie, the one that lived with the horses, he
became a veterinarian. Of the three of us kids, I became a registered nurse, my
sister became a medical doctor for the Native American Health Service, and I
always worked with mostly immigrant people and Black Americans as a nurse. My
sister was a public school teacher. We all grew up to very much feel that our
job was to serve the community, and particularly people who are living in
marginal lives. And I think that
00:24:00that was partly just because of my parents' values, even before they were
incarcerated, and perhaps made stronger by the fact that they had been through
that very unjust experience. And so it was all in our bones to make sure that
people who weren't getting an even chance in life got some support and help and
that we put our energies there.
TEWES: Yeah. So your mother's brother went to Colorado. What about her parents
and her sister?
KITAZAWA: I think he was in Colorado, I'm not sure. It was someplace in the
mountains and they called it a dude ranch. Her sister went to Arkansas, to the
center there. I don't know why she was sent there but she was sent there. And so
she was completely separated from the
00:25:00family. I know she carried some resentment about that, that the parents and my
mom were together, and Uncle Ernie got to go ride horses, and she was off in
Arkansas with no family. I think partly because of her isolation, she married
another Japanese American person while she was incarcerated there, which was a
marriage that did not last long and did not go well. She was still married to
him when they were released, but I think part of it was just she didn't really
have any family support system or anything. I don't know a lot about her
experience, other than that she talked about being bitter that she was shipped
off to a different place and cut off from family.
And then my mother's mother and my mother's father were in Manzanar.
00:26:00I never really heard much about what either of them did. I heard absolutely zero
from them about what they thought of the experience, partly because I did not
meet my mother's mother until I was twenty-six. And my mother's father came to
visit us several times a year when he was on break. He wasn't working at
Manzanar anymore. He got a similar job, seven days a week as a cook in another
rich boys boarding school in Upstate New York when we lived in New York State
and Pennsylvania, Massachusetts. So he lived closer. So he would take the
Greyhound bus and come visit us when he was on winter break and spring break and
sometimes Thanksgiving. And other than that, he was always working. But when he
came to see us, I don't remember him ever speaking about incarceration
00:27:00or really anything. I don't remember that grandfather speaking about anything at
all, zero, about his life history, other than: he was born in Japan; he came to
the US and he worked as a cook for rich families; and loved to gamble and loved
to ride roller coasters and blew whatever money he was making; and then went
back to Japan and ended up in an arranged marriage to my grandmother, who had
already been married once and had a son, which none of us knew about except for
my grandfather, until maybe the last year of his life.
00:28:00He didn't talk about camp, about relocation at all. He didn't talk about Japan
at all. The only thing he talked about was when he came to the US by himself and
worked for rich families as a cook. He had some money. So he gambled a lot. And
he loved to drink and he was a very, very functional alcoholic, I think.
Somebody who never drank that affected his work, but when he wasn't at work, he
was drinking whiskey. And he loved roller coasters and that's kind of all I know
about him. A gambling, drinking man who loved roller coasters, and who got
married to this woman who apparently had been married before and had a son. And
when her husband in Japan died, the husband's parents took the son, because he
was their male heir and sent her back to her parents, and then they remarried
her off to my grandfather.
So anyway, he came to the
00:29:00US. As soon as he found housing, my grandmother was supposed to follow him and
come here and live with him in California. But after he came here, they found
out my grandmother was already pregnant with my mother, and the rule back then
was you couldn't go on a ship if you were pregnant or if you were under two
years old, you know, across the Pacific [on a] ship. And so she had to stay in
Japan until my mom was two, and then they came to the United States and joined
him. I think already by then he was working as a cook, yeah. And then my
grandmother was schizophrenic, and back then I don't think anybody had the word
schizophrenic or knew. They just knew she was weird and talked to herself and
kind of wandered around talking to herself all the time.
00:30:00
And she was very well educated. She was from a silk merchant family in Japan.
She was from a very educated, higher-class background, but she ended up living
in this shed behind the dining hall in America and hallucinating. And should I
say this? Yes, because people need to talk about mental illness and how it
wasn't taken care of back in those days. When the kids weren't in school -- I
forget if my mom or my aunt told me this -- she used to lock the kids in the
closet, because she couldn't deal with them and they would just be in the
closet, sometimes all day, while my grandfather was working. It's a very
traumatic, terrible thing, but it's the truth that people should know about. In the
00:31:00past, mental illness was just seen as you're just a bad person. Why don't you
get your act together? So her mental illness very much affected my mom and my
aunt and my uncle, who thankfully, had the school staff to kind of keep it
together for them. And then that was still happening when she went to
incarceration. And then when they were released, the US government officials
said, "She's too mentally ill. She can't go with you. She has to go to a mental
hospital." And so she went to Modesto State Mental Hospital and was there for
twenty-five years and went through all those treatments that have now been
completely debunked as sort of torture for mentally ill people, but people
believed they worked. They wrapped you in a sheet like a mummy and put you on
the ground and dumped freezing cold water over you. That was called
00:32:00water treatment, I think. And then also she had a lot of electroshock therapy to
her brain while she was in there. Again, just the primitiveness and the sadness
of life for people who have mental illness.
One good thing that Ronald Reagan did when he was the Governor of California --
good for my grandmother -- was when he closed a lot of the state mental
hospitals and dumped all the mentally ill people out onto the streets, who are
now among the homeless people that we see, people who are not able to take care
of themselves on their own, my grandmother got sent to a board and care home,
where she lived out the rest of her life with a very, very, very nice lady, who
had about four or five people in her house. She and her husband ran the board
and care.
00:33:00And my grandmother was very happy there. She was still hallucinating, but she
wasn't harming herself or anyone else and she lived out the rest of her life
there. So when I was twenty-six I went out there to meet her, and that was the
first time I met her. It was pretty special. My parents said, "Don't go see her,
because she's mentally ill. She won't even know who you are. She'll just get
upset, she'll just yell." But she recognized and acknowledged my mother as her
child when my mom went to see her after she was there. She recognized me. She
said to me in Japanese, which I actually understood, "Oh, you're Fumi's
daughter." And I said, "Yes, I'm Fumi's daughter." Fumiko was my mom.
Unfortunately, when my aunt and uncle went to see her there as adults, she said,
"No, no, no. You're not my children. My children are still
00:34:00little. My children are still someplace else." And it was very hurtful for them
to not be acknowledged by their own mother. But she was mentally ill. So anyway,
I would go out to Modesto to see her at the board and care home and I would
usually visit her for about maybe fifteen minutes before she would start telling
me in a very agitated way, mostly in Japanese and partly in English, that I had
to take my kids and leave, leave, leave, because the police will come and
they'll take your kids, which seemed very psychotic to me. But I would just take
my kids and go home. And at the very end of my grandfather's life, probably the
last three months of his life, he told me how she had had a son in Japan and
that the son had been taken by the husband's parents after the husband died. She
had lost that
00:35:00son and been married to him and gone to the United States. So it was true. She
had a child that was taken away from her, and so that was not just her
schizophrenia. That was something that really happened to her, that you can have
a child and they can take your child away from you.
TEWES: Yeah. It sounds like she had a lot of traumatic experiences in her life
connected --
KITAZAWA: Yeah. And my mother never knew about this. And I called my mom and I
said, "How come you never told me you have a half-brother?" And she said, "What
are you talking about, Susan?" And I told her what my grandfather, what her
father had told me. And when my mom was eight and the other kids were younger,
the three of them went with their parents back to Japan for one year, because
the doctors had this idea that maybe she would get better if she got to go back
to Japan for a
00:36:00while. And my mother, when she was eight, had gone on this trip with her parents
and her siblings to Japan. And when I said, "No, Grandpa told me, like, Grandma
had a son before with her first marriage in Japan. The father died, they took
the brother back, the baby back." And my mother said, "Oh, that's who that boy
was." So then it was my turn. Like, "What boy? What are you talking about?" And
she said, "When we went to Japan, we went to visit an elderly couple, and there
was a boy there who was about a year-and-a-half older than me. And my mother was
instantly close to him and spent more time and attention on him than with us
three kids while we were in Japan. And I never really understood, like, why is
my mother so attached to this boy that we just met?" And she said, "That must
have been my
00:37:00 half-brother."
TEWES: Oh my goodness.
KITAZAWA: So that's another Japanese thing. If there's tough things, don't talk
about it, keep it sacred. I think that's very much part of the culture. So just
like there wasn't a lot of talk about Manzanar, there was no talk about what had
happened to my grandmother and her son and her first husband. I mean, nobody
knew. Only my grandfather knew. I think I was the first person he told, and it
was within months before he passed away.
TEWES: Wow.
KITAZAWA: Yeah. When he was, like, around his late eighties. I was at his
apartment once and he just told me this whole story all of a sudden.
TEWES: Whew, okay. Thank you for sharing that one. I think you're right. That's
important to tell, that certainly it was a tough
00:38:00family story to hear, too.
KITAZAWA: It also turns out that my father's aunt, right, his mom's sister -- I
told you his two brothers got married to two sisters in Japan. The sister, my
great aunt, she also had children in Japan that something happened. I don't know
what happened, but she was left behind and she was married off and came to the
US with her second husband. And that part of the family only later found out
that there were these ghost children in Japan, unspoken of. So I have a feeling
these stories are not unique. I have a feeling that there's a lot of other
people, especially women, who lost their kids somehow and got married
00:39:00off by arranged marriage to somebody else and they didn't have any say.
TEWES: Yeah. Well, thank you for sharing that. I did want to touch back on your
parents. Did they meet while on the Guayule Project?
KITAZAWA: There are different versions of reality. My mother says, yes, that
they definitely met when they were fellow researchers on the Guayule Project and
that they met there in Manzanar for the first time. And my father, when my
mother would talk about this -- like this was a story I think I heard many, many
times as a kid. Like anytime anybody would ask how they met, my father would say
they met on the Guayule Project. And my mother would say, somewhat indignantly
-- no, she would say they met on the Guayule Project, and he would always say,
somewhat indignantly,
00:40:00"No. No, Fumi. We met at Berkeley. We met at that party at I-House," which is
short for International House, "at Berkeley." And we talked for a long time,
like maybe an hour. And he had this very clear memory and he would say things
like, "Yeah, you were working as a live-in babysitter for this family, and you
told me that and you were majoring in the sciences, too." He would go on and on
about this wonderful meeting with her at UC Berkeley at a party. And she would
go, "No, no, George. I don't remember you at all. You must have been talking to
somebody else." And he said, "No, no. Because when I first saw you at Manzanar,
I was like, Oh my God. There's that wonderful lady that I met at Berkeley at the
party." He was apparently already smitten with her by the time they met in
Manzanar. But my mom says, "I don't
00:41:00 remember."
TEWES: What do you think about that?
KITAZAWA: It was just kind of a joke in the family, of just, "Yeah, okay, Papa.
I guess you didn't really make a big impression on mom." And he says, "Oh yeah,
I thought she was beautiful and smart." And my mom goes, "I don't remember that
at all, George." That was a funny story in the family. And they would kind of
mock argue about it, even though we'd heard this story a whole lot of times.
They would kind of go back and forth, like, "No, I met you." And "No, no. I
don't remember it at all." So there's a little question about where my parents met.
TEWES: [both laugh] Got it. Do you know if the project was onsite in Manzanar or
was it offsite?
KITAZAWA: Yes, it was onsite. And it conveniently was in the middle of the
desert, where there was a lot of Guayule cactus
00:42:00growing. I don't know if it was a cactus. It was like some kind of succulent
plant. I think -- and I might be 100 percent wrong -- I think it's kind of like
aloe, shaped like that. Just like aloe has that really soupy sap to it that
people use for lotion and stuff, I think the Guayule had some kind of real juicy
fluid in it that they did -- they eventually succeeded in synthesizing rubber by
the end of the project. But it was late, [too late to be used in the war
effort]. The war was pretty much over, so they didn't need to make synthetic
rubber. Because they were having rubber shortages like for the wheels for the
airplanes and stuff like that, so that's why they wanted to make synthetic rubber.
TEWES: Right.
KITAZAWA: It was the government's idea.
TEWES: Do you have a sense of what your parents felt about that, working towards
the war effort while also being
00:43:00 incarcerated?
KITAZAWA: They were both very deeply science people, so just to be able -- it's
like my grandfather, who had a nursery, being able to be in charge of the
victory garden. It was like, Oh, I get to use my best skills even though I'm
locked up. And my parents were very much science research-type people. And so
for them to be able to continue that within incarceration, they felt very, very
fortunate that they got to do that. And also, my father was a US-born citizen,
he was American. Japan bombed Pearl Harbor and attacked the US -- Hawaii wasn't
part of the US then -- but attacked US forces. So they
00:44:00were very much on the side of America, that we needed to win the war against the
Japanese imperialist military government and win the war against Hitler. My
parents were very deeply Americans. And the one thing where my father drew the
line is when people signed up to be in the military to fight. He was like, "No.
No way am I going to join the Army while my family's incarcerated." And he was
kind of down on the people who did that, although later he came to really,
profoundly respect the 442nd and everything. But at the time he was
incarcerated, he was like, "There's no way I'm going to go fight for the US
government while my family is still locked up." But while they were locked
00:45:00up, I think they felt good about -- that they were doing something constructive
for the war effort. Like you're not going to go out and kill other people for
the war effort, but they would do the research.
Or like another job in Manzanar was making camouflage nets. So weaving strips of
brown and green cloth into netting to make camouflage tarps to put over tanks
and things. And so a lot of people were making camouflage nets. And I think a
lot of people felt okay about helping the war effort, but they weren't about to
go out there and get shot at and kill other people, to that extent to help the
war effort when their families were locked up. Although a lot of people did go
into the service.
TEWES: Right. And the last time we mentioned
00:46:00that when they were released your parents went to Upstate New York for your
father's education. Do you have a sense of why they chose Upstate New York and
not to return to California?
KITAZAWA: Well, they didn't have a choice. And again, everything I say, it's
like what I've been told, because I wasn't there then.
TEWES: That's fine.
KITAZAWA: My father and mother both said that they were told they could be
released on the condition that they leave the State of California. And so like
old people like my grandparents could go back home, but the young people that I
think the government still saw as a threat, like you still might do something
bad or something. I don't know. It's kind of like after 9/11. If you're an old
person, okay, you're Muslim, but we'll let you hang around, but we don't want
these young hotheads
00:47:00around. Like the younger people, my understanding was, were strongly encouraged
or required to leave the state, to get out of the area. And I think also they
were trying to deconcentrate the number of Japanese Americans in the area, I
think. I don't really know. All I know is that going out of state was pretty
much something that they felt they had to do. I think if it was totally up to
them, they would have gone back to Berkeley. Because they liked being at UC
Berkeley. But that wasn't really an option for them. And so I don't know how
they did it, but I think people got sponsors in other places. They would sponsor
them in jobs or sponsor them to get into some academic program. And I know there
was this man, Dr. Forsythe, who was somehow instrumental in my
00:48:00father's being in that PhD program in Syracuse, New York. And so they went there
and I met Dr. Forsythe when I was maybe twelve or fourteen or something, because
my parents kept in touch with him and his wife, because they had been supportive
of them and helpful right after they got out. So I think it was just like he
probably wrote letters and found: where is there a good program that would match
what I want to do? And then Dr. Forsythe, I think, was like the sponsor. Kind of
like someone who's going to be responsible for you. That's your connection in
the community. And so if my father started doing something bad, then Dr.
Forsythe's taking responsibility for him, if that makes any sense.
TEWES: Yeah,
00:49:00yeah. Now, you mentioned that your parents really started talking about some of
this later in life. And I'm wondering how, beyond talking to your family, you
learned about the history of incarceration. Was that through school or some
other research?
KITAZAWA: Okay. Well, definitely not through school. You have to remember, I'm
going to school right in the 1950s and 60s, before the US civil rights
legislation passed, when it was still legal to have whites-only covenants on
towns for deeds, and it was perfectly all right to say, "I'm not going to hire
you, because you're Black." It was completely legal to be totally
discriminatory. So certainly, they weren't going to talk about how the US
government locked up US citizens in the
00:50:00desert. So that wasn't part of my schooling at all. Most of the people I was
around didn't even know what happened.
How I first learned about all of this was I knew my parents had met while they
were incarcerated, and I knew they were incarcerated because they were Japanese
American. And I knew that even if you were a citizen, you could be incarcerated.
And I don't even remember when I learned this, but I think I was very, very
young, like five or six years old. And that it was a bad experience and that it
was in California, and we're in New York, so we don't have to think about that.
It was pretty darn clear that it just wasn't something we talked about. Just
like I knew very early that my father's brother and sister had died when they
were little, and that my mother's mother was schizophrenic. But those were just
all things that we just don't talk about, because they're bad things, so we just don't
00:51:00talk about it. But there was a book called -- if I can remember the number right
-- Citizen 13660, I think.
TEWES: Yes.
KITAZAWA: 13660. And it was written by a woman artist, Miné Okubo. Okubo was
incarcerated. She was also in Manzanar. And even though you weren't supposed to
keep records of what was going on, like you weren't allowed to take photos or
anything, except for Dorothea Lange, who the US government interestingly
commissioned to do all these pictures about incarceration -- I don't exactly
know why but she did. But anyway, so Miné Okubo was someone who liked art. I
think she was in her twenties when she was incarcerated. And so she began making
all these black and white ink
00:52:00drawings of daily life in Manzanar. And then there's this book, Citizen 13660,
and each page is about three-quarters filled up with one of her drawings, and
then at the bottom there's just maybe three or four sentences about what's in
that picture. And it's a chronological history of the time that they got
gathered up in the assembly centers and shipped off in the trains and when they
got to the center and their life there. And I don't remember if it goes up to
when they were released. But this book was in our home ever since I can
remember. And so if we asked anything about incarceration and that time in their
life, we were told, "Well, just look at the book. You can see in the book." I
think it's kind of like how people who are very uncomfortable with
00:53:00sexuality, when their kids ask questions about sex, they just get handed a book.
"Here, read this book, but don't talk to me." And it was very similar to that.
Just, "Okay, you can know about this. Just look at the book but don't ask me
about it." Before we could read, we would just pore over the pictures in the
book. And then later, when we could read, we read the book. And so I just grew
up with that book in our house. Through all the different moves that we made, we
just had that book. And so that's how I knew about the barracks and the latrines
and the dining hall, and the sand blowing all the time into your food and your
bed and your teeth, and the guard towers and the soldiers and the guns. I
learned all that from that book.
TEWES: It's so funny to me that they kept that in the house.
KITAZAWA: Yeah, yeah. I know one
00:54:00time when I was somewhere in elementary school in Pennsylvania, I forget what
year, but I don't know, for some reason we had to talk about our families or how
our parents met or something like that, and so I said my parents met when they
were locked up in the prison camp. And the teacher got really mad at me and
said, "You're supposed to tell the truth. Don't make things up." And I said,
"No, that really happened. And my parents told me that." And the teacher said,
"Your parents lied. Nothing like that ever happened in the United States." And
she got really angry at me. And I felt really bad, because she thought not only
that I was lying, but that my parents were lying to me. And so my mother said I
could take the book to school and show her the book. And I showed her the book
and she just brushed it off like, "Yeah, whatever. That was stupid. Things like
that don't happen in America." And
00:55:00so from that experience, I learned to just kind of shut up about it. I just
didn't talk with people much about it.
And then I remember, okay, when I was maybe in eleventh or twelfth grade, I was
very active in Girl Scouts. There are two centers that the Girl Scouts have. One
of them is in Switzerland, it's called Our Chalet, and the other one is called
Our Cabaña and it's in Mexico. And these are international Girl Scout centers.
And if you're really a super good Girl Scout and have been really active and
contributed, you can apply. I think they had scholarships to go, like, for a
week on this international experience where you would meet Girl Scouts from all
over the world. And I was really excited about going. You write essays and then
you get chosen for an interview. And I remember I was in the
00:56:00finalists. I was down to the last few girls who were being considered to go to
Switzerland to Our Chalet. And they asked me all these questions and I think
even though I was really shy then I did a good job of answering. And then the
last question was, "We know you're Japanese American and we're wondering if
anyone in your family had anything to do with the Japanese Americans being in
what they called relocation camps." And I said, "Yes, my parents and my
grandparents, my aunts and uncles, everybody who's a little bit older than me
was in there." It was a panel of three older white women. And one of them said,
"So if you go to Switzerland, to Our Chalet, and anybody asks you about this,
what would you say?" And I said that I would tell them that, "It was a mistake
that the American
00:57:00government and American people made. And it was based on war hysteria, that
people thought anybody who even looked like the Japanese enemy was the enemy,
even if you were born in the US and you were a citizen, like my father, by
birth, and that they thought that somehow the Japanese Americans were going to
aid Japan in the war effort. And that that was a mistake, and that they just
built up this whole hysteria about it and convinced other people that people
like my parents had to be locked up." And then the interview situation turned to
ice and they said, "So you would criticize your country?" And I said, "Well,
it's not happening now, but they made a really bad mistake then." And then they
just said, "This interview's over." And so
00:58:00I obviously did not get to go to Switzerland.
TEWES: What did you learn from that experience?
KITAZAWA: Pardon?
TEWES: What did you learn from that experience?
KITAZAWA: I learned that if you're interviewing for something that you really
want, that you shouldn't talk about this, even if they ask about it. I should've
just said, "I don't know. My parents didn't talk about it," although I don't
think that I really believed that. I mean, I knew people were already pretty
racist about things, so I didn't really learn that. But I was just shocked that
it came up in the interview. I mean, they brought it up; I didn't bring it up.
And I guess I didn't really learn my lesson that time. Like there was the time
that my teacher said my parents and I were lying when I was probably in about
third grade. Got shot down then. Got shot down at the Girl Scout
00:59:00 interview.
And then once when I was in my thirties, I was on my first round of interviews
to get a job as a registered nurse, because I was close to graduation. And I
went to a job interview, and also the white female interviewer at the end of the
interview, just regular interview questions, she said, "What's something that
you really care about, that you like?" So I answered. And then she said, "What's
something that you don't like that makes you angry?" And I said, "I don't like
it when people treat other people in a racist manner." And she started yelling
at me and said, "I'm not racist. I'm not being racist toward you." And I said,
"I wasn't talking about you. You just asked me 'what is something I don't
like.'" And I said, "That's something I don't like, when people are racist
toward each other. Like
01:00:00how people treat Black people. I don't like that." And she goes, "Well, I'm not
a racist and this interview's over." So that was probably the most recent time,
which was a long time ago, that I just got totally shot down for bringing up
injustice or racism in an interview kind of situation. But I'm retired now, so I
don't have to go to job interviews, and I will. I will speak up about like
what's truth. This is what's truth, this is what happened. Sometimes that makes
other people really uncomfortable, but that's their problem.
TEWES: That's a good observation.
KITAZAWA: And I think a lot of times people who have had marginalized
experiences, like
01:01:00incarceration or mental illness, either as a relative or as themselves or as
being treated badly, because they're gay or lesbian or in some other kind of
minority group, that people do get shot down and people get bashed verbally and
I think that it does have an effect. It can have an effect on us and silencing
us, and just not speaking of our experiences or at least choosing carefully who
we tell of our experiences. And I think that's one thing that's starting to
change since George Floyd was murdered, was it's really becoming more of a
movement. That, hey, not everyone in this country has had the same experience,
and just because you haven't had that experience, doesn't mean we haven't had
01:02:00that experience. And don't discount our experience. Don't tell us not to talk
about it. Don't silence us, either directly or indirectly, because we're going
to talk about our truth. And that's partly why I agreed to do these interviews,
is because I think that it's really important that what are called under-told
stories are told. And I think it helps all the people, whatever their untold or
under-told story is, to feel more empowered to speak their truth, to speak of
what happened to them and to name it and to describe it and not to just be
directly or indirectly encouraged to just keep it to themselves, get over it.
"That was a long time ago. You're just being oversensitive."
TEWES: Yeah. I appreciate you --
KITAZAWA:
01:03:00"You're talking about something that happened hundreds of years ago, just forget
about it." It's like, no, we're not going to forget about it.
TEWES: I appreciate you drawing that through line. Something you mentioned
earlier was language, and the language people were using to describe these
experiences. And I've been saying "incarceration" throughout. What did you grow
up calling these experiences?
KITAZAWA: We grew up calling it "camp." My parents met and married at camp.
Sounds like Girl Scout summer camp. You live in tents and go swimming in the
lake and eat hotdogs over the bonfire. It was always camp. And I think a large
portion of the Japanese American community of the age of people who actually
went call it
01:04:00camp. All my older relatives call it camp. I don't know, I hardly ever heard
anybody call it anything except camp who was actually in it. And then it kind of
shifted to being "internment," internment camp. "When we were in the internment
camp," blah, blah, blah. And then my father was one of the people who started
using the word incarceration and would say -- actually, no. I take that back. He
didn't say incarceration; he said "concentration camp." And there were quite a
few people starting to say concentration camp. And then there was some pushback
from some people within the Jewish community, that, "What you guys went through
was not the Holocaust concentration camps, that you're elevating it to a degree
of terribleness. You're equating it to
01:05:00our people's experience and it's not really that." And so even though the word
concentration from a language point of view just means you've taken a group of
people and concentrated them in one area, that I understand the people in the
Jewish community who feel that we're taking over a word that doesn't belong to
us. And so calling it incarceration or incarceration centers gets around that
conflict there. And since then, I myself, personally, I will talk about my
parents, my relatives were -- I will usually, if I can remember, use the term
incarceration centers. My parents, my people were in incarceration centers. And
if I'm talking about what the
01:06:00Nazis were doing in Jewish -- I will usually call them extermination centers.
They weren't just concentrating people there, they were actively intent on
exterminating all the Jews. And so that's how I differentiate it, is the Jewish
people were sent to extermination centers where the focus was on exterminating
their people and our people were incarcerated, they weren't just at camp. But as
my mother said after they were there for a while, "We realized that probably
they weren't going to kill us." At first both of my parents said they were
afraid that maybe they were going to be killed. But then after they were there
for a while and could start their own schools and Boy Scout troops and garden
and everything, that, "Okay, they're just going to keep us locked
01:07:00up who knows how long, but they don't intend to kill us."
TEWES: Thank you for sharing that.
KITAZAWA: Unless you get too close to the fence. And then even if you're not
trying to escape, you get too close to the fence and you're dead. As the young
man who walked too close to the fence at Manzanar was shot to death by one of
the people in the guard tower. I mean --
TEWES: Yeah. How did you hear about that?
KITAZAWA: How did I know about that?
TEWES: Yeah. Did your parents tell you or did you have to research that?
KITAZAWA: That might have been in Miné Okubo's book. I don't remember. I just
know I knew as a kid that one guy was shot to death, because he walked too close
to the fence and that he wasn't, from what I understood, wasn't trying to
escape. He just made the mistake of getting too close to the fence. He was just
looking out over the fence when they killed him. And then my parents at some
point did talk
01:08:00about when that young man was shot. There was rioting. I don't know if it was
rioting, but protests, and there was a lot of uproar at Manzanar. And my father
was very negative about those people, too, that they were putting everybody's
lives at risk by causing this disturbance. And I think probably his own self
sense was that, "They'll just kill all of us if we don't behave ourselves."
That's like all I know about that, and I don't exactly know how I know about it,
but I knew when I was young that one person got killed for walking too close to
the fence. A guy, a young guy.
TEWES: Thank
01:09:00 you.
KITAZAWA: I think I share this in common with a lot of Black Americans, which a
lot of my Black American friends have been surprised to hear. But when my father
taught me how to drive when I was sixteen, he taught me that if you -- I don't
know if I already talked about this. If you see the police red lights in back of
you, pull over the first place that's safe, park the car.
TEWES: Yeah, you mentioned that.
KITAZAWA: Yeah, and just put your hands on top of the steering wheel and freeze.
The message there was, "Because if you don't, they might kill you." And I think
that that was a subtext of how my father saw the world, of just, "You better
behave yourself, because otherwise they might kill you." And another thing I
remember him telling me is, "If someone has a gun, don't ever make the person
nervous or
01:10:00afraid or they might hurt you, because they're scared. Like keep your hands
where they can see you. Don't move quickly. If anybody, law enforcement or
otherwise, if anybody has a gun or a lethal weapon, your job is to not scare
them or upset them or make them feel threatened."
TEWES: Wow.
KITAZAWA: I don't think white suburban kids get that lesson.
TEWES: No, I suspect most do not. No. I also want to talk about memorialization
of those who have been incarcerated, and particularly pilgrimages. I know you've
been to one at Manzanar. Can you tell me when that was and how that came about?
KITAZAWA: I don't remember what year it was.
01:11:00I just can't help you at all with that one. My sisters and I had -- especially
my middle sister, the one two years younger than I -- we had been kind of
urging, I shall say, urging Papa that they have these pilgrimages in California.
Because we both lived in California at that time. Trying to encourage him that
maybe it would be good to go on the pilgrimage to Manzanar. And he was just
completely, utterly dead set against it. It was like telling him he should go to
Belarus or Mars. There was just no way was he going to go to Manzanar. And then
I don't know what turned him around exactly. I think part of it was that his
very good friends, Irwin and Sara Fischbein, a Jewish couple who had helped him
get his first real science research job after he got out of his
01:12:00PhD program. He had really, really, really crummy jobs, and then Irwin helped
him get his first real research scientist job. So they were long-time buddies.
They knew my parents before we were born. So Irwin and Sara said they were
really interested, and they would meet him there at Manzanar if he would go with
me. They're Jewish so they have the whole Holocaust history, not themselves but
their families. So I don't know. Somehow this got set up.
So I met our father in LA, and we drove up to Manzanar and Irwin and Sara drove
up and we met them there. And we drove up separately. And then when we got
there, we parked the car outside the fence and my father got out of the car and
he was looking over the barbed wire fence into the area where
01:13:00the internment camp was, and he looked really confused. And my father was not at
this time the tiniest bit demented or Alzheimer's or anything, his brain was
totally sharp until the day he died. And he was standing there looking really
confused and he said, "Sue, where are all the people? What happened to the
barracks that the people live in? Where is everybody?" Oh, before he said that,
when he just said, "Where are all the people?" I thought he meant the tour group
that was going to go through the site. And I said, "Oh, Papa, they're probably
over by the main entrance. They're probably gathering there." And then that was
when he said, "No, but where are all the people, the ones that live in the
barracks? Where are the barracks?" And that was when I realized he was expecting
to get out and see like the scene he had left when he was in his
01:14:00twenties, like, still going on. And I said, "Papa, it's like you and mom, like,
everybody left a long time ago. Like, they tore the barracks down. Nobody lives
here anymore." And then he was embarrassed and he kind of goes, "Oh, oh, oh.
Yeah, right. Of course, of course." And then he said, "Oh, you're right. The
people are probably over by the gate. Let's walk over and join them." But there
was that moment of him being utterly confused. And I realized in that moment how
traumatized he was, that in his mind, it was still real, it was still happening.
And for him to go back and visit there was just going back to the scene of a
terrible, terrible thing, and he just didn't want to have anything to do with it.
So anyway, we went over to the people by the gate, we joined the tour. There was
a young man with a microphone and a loudspeaker
01:15:00box and there were maybe half-a-dozen younger people who were in charge of the
tour, and then a lot of the people who were on the tour were people who'd been
incarcerated as younger children. Because a lot of the people my father's age
had already passed, right. So we were walking around and the guide would say,
"Here was such and such." And then my father would say, "Actually, I think the
dining hall was a little bit farther that way." And then he would say something
else, like there was such and such here. And my father would say, "No, actually,
that was da, da, da." And so after he did that a few times, the young man
leading the tour, he goes, "You lived this, sir. Why don't you lead the tour,
because you know what it was?" And so my father somewhat hesitantly took the mic
and he led the rest of the tour. And it was just this incredibly healing
experience for
01:16:00him. It was amazing. And his friends, Irwin and Sara, were there, and they were
able to talk with him. It was just wonderful for him. I was just so grateful
that the Manzanar Pilgrimages exist, because for my father, it was this
incredibly healing experience.
It was before they were starting to try to make it into a national historic site
or park or whatever it is now. And he actually started writing letters to the
Department of the Interior and stuff to support that effort to make it
recognized as a historical site. And also after that trip was when the local
elementary school heard about this guy who'd been incarcerated and they invited
him to come to speak to elementary school classrooms, and he went and talked to
some of the older elementary school kids about his experience. It was just an
incredible, wonderful experience for
01:17:00him that just opened things up for him.
And then later, going to the newly opened exhibit on incarceration that was at
the Smithsonian Institute. The first night that that section was open, you could
only go if you had been incarcerated and my father went with his buddy, Mike,
who was one of his ham radio friends, and they went. And my father walked
through, and he said it was really quiet, and all you could hear was a lot of
people crying quietly. And he said, "As I walked through, I became more and more
enraged. Like, how could they do this to these people? This is so unjust, this
is so wrong, this is just absolutely stupid." And he said, "I just found myself
being enraged and
01:18:00furious. That how could the government, how could [it] do this to these people?"
And then he said all of a sudden he thought, "Oh, I was one of the people." And
he said, "It just hit me like, Oh, this was done to me and mom and my parents."
And he said, "I realized to deal with the pain -- " he didn't use this language,
but basically he just said he had disassociated himself from the experience,
because it was just so painful and hadn't owned his own experience or owned his
own feelings about it. And he later told me that instead of the rage he felt
that evening walking through the exhibit or that afternoon, he said, "I always
felt ashamed." He said, "I was like an ex-convict. I had been incarcerated. I
was an
01:19:00ex-convict. I was ashamed. And partly why I didn't talk about it was because I
didn't want you kids to think of me as an ex-convict." Which just blew my mind.
And he said, "Yeah, I always felt shame, like somehow I had done something
wrong." And I said, "Yeah, you did something really wrong, Papa. You were born
into a Japanese American body. That was your crime." And he goes, "Yeah. Like I
just never got it before, that that's how I had it programmed into my brain,
that I did something wrong."
TEWES: Wow.
KITAZAWA: Yeah. And even though he was very much, "We are Americans. We should
be proud of ourselves, we should be proud of our heritage -- " he talked all
that even when we were kids. But deep inside of him he was carrying this huge
shame that he wasn't a real American and that he wasn't a real person deserving
of what other
01:20:00people deserve, and that somehow, he had done something wrong and that he
deserved this experience. So that all kind of blew my mind, just listening to
him. Wow, that's really heavy.
TEWES: Susan, let me ask you: when you were at Manzanar on this pilgrimage, what
was it like for you being in that space after having heard about it and read
about it for years? What did that bring up for you?
KITAZAWA: Hard for me to say. I think I was just so focused on my father and
just getting him through the experience. I liked being there with a bunch of
Japanese American people who were paying attention to this and advocating for it
being remembered and everything. And
01:21:00then this is kind of weird. My mom, whenever my father would occasionally talk
bitterly about incarceration, my mom's reply was -- and I heard this many times
-- "But the mountains were so beautiful," because it's right next to the
mountains and a lot of the year there's snow on the mountains. And my mother
would always say, "But the mountains were so beautiful." And I looked at the
mountains when I was there and I thought, Mom was right. The mountains are so
beautiful. This is like this horrible, unjust -- [coughs] excuse me -- messed
up, stupid thing. And yet, yeah, at the same time it's going on, the mountains
were beautiful. And she said, "Every morning I would get up and look at the
mountains and just think, The mountains are so beautiful." And I think that's part
01:22:00of -- because my mom had such a difficult life with her schizophrenic mother and
everything, she just learned early on as a coping thing to not forget the part
of the glass that's half full, and that no matter what's going on there's
something positive. And you're not making less of the negative, but you are just
also not forgetting the positive. And I distinctly remember thinking, She's
right. The mountains are beautiful. And my mom had passed on by then, you know?
And I was just glad. I think my experience of being there was just more -- just
seeing how incredibly healing this was for our father. This was so good and so
healing for Papa. And I think only later, I was
01:23:00processing, like, my father wasn't the easiest person to be around sometimes.
He's very demanding, very strict. Nothing you did was good enough. "Oh, you got
an A minus. Why did you get the minus?" Very typical Asian American, driving you
to be perfect. And I think it was just another layer of understanding, like, how
traumatized he was and how much his behavior has a parent was driven by the fact
that he was so traumatized and just wanted things to be okay for his kids. And
we had to be perfect and get straight As and get good jobs, because you never
know when they're going to come and take it all away from you. But I didn't
think that while I was there. That was afterwards, reflecting on it, like, Wow,
he was so traumatized. He thought we were going to pull up in the car and there
were going to be all these
01:24:00people walking around inside the barbed wire that were captive there. It was amazing.
TEWES: Do you have any interest in returning for yourself without your father now?
KITAZAWA: My first thought was as a legally blind person who doesn't have
wheels, God, I'd just like to go to the grocery store and get food. I'd just
like it to be easier to go to the doctor's appointments. It's like going to the
Mojave Desert. Like what? Well, it's kind of like I don't see myself as getting
there, just because, how am I going to get there?
01:25:00But I mean, I've been to Cambodia. It's easier to go to Cambodia, because you
take the airport or bus, you get on the plane, you go to Cambodia, and then you
go on the tour of Cambodia. But how do I get to the Mojave Desert? I'm not sure
how one would do that. But I would like to go back if I can get a ride in a car
and go there, because I would like to go see what they did now that they made it
into a historical center. Because I think there's a museum there now and I think
they might have reconstructed one of the barracks or something. I think that
it's pretty changed from when we were there when it was just basically bare dirt
and a bunch of half-dead plants. I would like to go see what they did with it,
and I would like to go with someone who can drive who would share my
01:26:00interest in seeing it.
TEWES: Right.
KITAZAWA: It's something that I wish my kids were even vaguely interested in --
my adopted son from Vietnam and our birth daughter -- but they're just not. It's
just totally not something they're interested in. I mean, not just Manzanar, but
just the whole package.
TEWES: I want to pivot in our last few minutes together and ask briefly about
your creative outlets. I know you are an artist in several different media. Can
you tell me about some of the work you do?
KITAZAWA: Yeah. I'll talk a little about that. Before I talk about that, I think
just something I want to say is that seeing the profound effect on my
01:27:00father of going to Manzanar, of the huge healing effect for him of going to
Manzanar and of going to the Smithsonian exhibit with his buddy, Mike -- which
I've also gone to see that exhibit myself -- and just the healing that comes. I
just think that in general, African American history museum, slavery history
museums, Holocaust museums, all those things for all people who've been through
stupid stuff, it's so important, because it can bring healing for the people who
actually experience these things or their offspring. And I also think that it
brings more understanding to the general public, that these were real things.
And something that I would love to see in our country, around the world, but
especially here because I'm an American, I would love to see a
01:28:00fantastic like bunch of national museums in all the major cities, of something
that combines like a museum. The Smithsonian kind of does this, right, because
they have the African American culture and history center now and they have the
part about the Japanese American. I would love to see it all in one museum, like
this unification of all sorts of people have gone through this stuff and the
commonalities between all of it, and what's happening to the Central American
people who are coming on foot across Mexico now and being stuck in cages at the
border. A museum where the theme is, yes, these things really happen and they're
still happening, and they're happened to all different kinds of people. And
everybody who's affected by these kinds of things, including very poor white
disenfranchised European Americans, that we have this common
01:29:00ground, and we need to work together. And that's something that I care about
passionately, and I would love to see museums and books and everything, that
they're not so siloed. The Black people's thing and the Asian people's thing and
the Mexican people's thing, I would love to see more cross-group collaborations.
So that was the thing I was going to say and now I'll talk to you about my artwork.
TEWES: That's great. Thank you.
KITAZAWA: Unless you want to ask me.
TEWES: I think that was perfect.
KITAZAWA: Okay. My creative stuff, my writing and my visual, tactile art, I have
absolutely no need to market it, sell it. I don't have a website. People are
like, "How can you not have a website?" It's really easy not to have a website.
I do a lot of it for just the process of self-discovery and self-healing. And
then I've also
01:30:00found that in sharing it, by getting things published and by being in art shows,
that it can have in a very small way the same effect that the Manzanar tour had
on my father. Of people who feel left out looking at it and going, "Oh yes. That
makes me think of my grandparents." I have a piece that speaks to my
schizophrenic grandmother's experience, it's a piece of art. And I have a piece
that is combining my parents' Manzanar experience with the current thing that's
going on for Latino people at the border, at the US border. And I have haiku
that I wrote in English and in Spanish integrated into the piece. Again, trying
to tie together that it's not just one group that's having things happen, it's all
01:31:00tied together. My writing is like that, too. It's using my experience and my
family's experience and trying to tie it together as well as I can with, in some
way, everybody. Even the people that are doing horrible, terrible things from
high up on to other people, it's like, What the heck happened to you that just
destroyed your soul so much that you don't get what you're doing to other
people? And one of my haiku in that one piece, I think it's in Spanish, is like,
some line about, "How do we forgive the jailers?" And not to say that what they
did or are doing is right, but unless we see those people as our fellow human
01:32:00beings, we are working from a place of less power. And until we see all people,
all people, even people who are our absolute enemies, as our fellow human beings
and try to understand where they're coming from, we're not going to be able to
really change things. That's what I believe. I mean, we can change things,
absolutely, always, but to really bring fundamental foundational change to the
world, we have to know that everybody matters, and even people that we dislike
and don't agree with, they matter. And that we need to listen to each other and
understand each other's stories. That's --
TEWES: Does this emphasis --
KITAZAWA: -- something I believe. Sorry, go ahead.
TEWES:
01:33:00Does this emphasis on forgiveness connect to your religious beliefs?
KITAZAWA: Kind of. But I think that that's there in me, just like my parents'
activism was in them before they were incarcerated. And maybe institutions and
books and whatnot have helped give me vocabulary to speak about how I feel. I
was raised outside the church. We only went to church very briefly. My father
was an atheist, my mother was an agnostic -- although my father was raised
within the Christian church himself. I'm not a really churchy person. I think
about religion quite differently than many people do. I don't think of God as a
01:34:00big man in the sky who's going to fix things for me if I pray enough or if I'm
good enough. I just don't see things that way. But there's a lot of research and
stuff on forgiveness in more recent years. If we don't forgive, whether it's our
sister, our literal sister, or our boss or whatever, we're suffering from that.
Like living in a state where you have not forgiven somebody else takes away
something from you. And it also really gets in the way of resolving problems. So
I don't think that's so much from my religion. Yeah, I don't think it is at all
really. It's just something I believe. There's a wonderful saying, which I've
heard is not credited to anybody and I've heard it credited to different
01:35:00people, "Resentment is the poison we drink to try to kill the other person." And
I think that that's true. If you harbor resentment and lack of forgiveness and
anger, you're poisoning yourself and you're getting in the way of living a full,
meaningful, rich life, and you're destroying the chance to work out things
between you and other people. So that's just what I believe.
TEWES: Got it, thank you.
KITAZAWA: And it's not from a goody two-shoes point of view, like, Oh, you
should be a forgiving, kind, caring person. I just like being happy and I like
enjoying my life and I like being able to take in the world. And if I'm walking
around thinking, Gosh darn, that guy is such a frigging idiot. Why did he do
that? Da, da,
01:36:00da, I'm not having a good time. If I'm walking around thinking, Why did they
traumatize my parents so much, what did they do that for, that's just horrible
and wrong -- and it is, I totally believe that. And yet if I get stuck there,
I'm going to be a less effective human being in working to correct things that
are currently going badly for people, including for myself. And just being stuck
in a negative place, it's not fun and it's not productive.
TEWES: Susan, this is a great segue to my final question for you. How would you
define healing around this intergenerational history you have with
01:37:00 incarceration?
KITAZAWA: That's a good question for a nurse. [laughs] Healing, healthcare. I
think for us to heal, whether it's physically or emotionally, it's like you have
to let go and undo the damage and the painful stuff in our bodies. Grow new,
fresh tissue and in our {inaudible} grow new, stronger, more useful ways to
think about things. I for myself, I am a crier. I cry about a lot of things. One
of my friends told me a therapist said to her, "Beneath almost all anger and
rage is fear and pain. And so sometimes when we're
01:38:00really angry and enraged about things that are happening now or that happened in
the past, what's underneath that? What's the fear, what's the sadness underneath
that?" For example, related to incarceration. Just grieve what my parents went
through. Just sit down and just cry that this happened to them and that it's
horrible and that I'm going to do what I can do to try to not have it happen to
somebody else. And sometimes, the healing process is difficult. I mean, like if
you have an infected abscess wound in your leg, you can't just put a bandage
over it. You've got to lance it, which hurts, and you've got to let the pus
drain out and you've got to put stuff in there that might not feel too good to
clean it, and then you
01:39:00can bandage it. And I think that emotional and spiritual pain is the same way,
that you have to go sometimes deeper into the pain and the hurt and the
woundedness before you can come out the other side and grow a fresh way of
being, if that makes sense. Or even if it doesn't make sense, that's what I think.
TEWES: Yes. It does, thank you. Well, that's the end of my questions, Susan. Is
there anything you want to make sure we add that we haven't already discussed?
KITAZAWA: No, not really. I just would want to leave people with the thought of
just whatever each of us still needs to heal, which most of us have a lot of
things we need to heal, that we just have the courage to keep working on that
and that we also just reach
01:40:00across all the seemingly uncrossable divides between ourselves and other
individuals or between our group and other groups and have the deep faith that
it is possible to bridge those divides, as difficult as it sometimes -- or as
impossible as it sometimes seems, given things that have already happened. So
that's all.
TEWES: Thank you, I appreciate that. And thank you so much for your time. I
appreciate that, as well. I'll close us out here.
[End of Interview]
01:41:00